Much has been made of the increasing significance of the Latino vote in the U.S. political arena. As the number of U.S. Hispanics continues to grow, so, too, does their political sway. So how has the mainstream and Hispanic media responded to this reality, and how has it influenced their coverage?
According to Dr. Federico Subervi, author of The Mass Media and Latino Politics, a book that examines Hispanic-related media content and campaign strategies over the past twenty years, “Spanish-language media does a better job than mainstream media, but the coverage is still not as substantive as it should be, particularly with regard to mobilizing Hispanics to become more involved.” One problem, he says, is that that the mainstream media focuses more on the spectacle of a politician campaigning in Hispanic areas—and on the fiestas and cultural notes that they hit—than on the pressing issues that face Hispanics and are at stake in their political choices. Some will remember the not-prescient photo of Senator Clinton drinking Presidente Beer in Puerto Rico while campaigning there—an example of the colorful, but vacuous, treatment of Hispanic political outreach that is typical of the mainstream media, according to Dr. Subervi.
While the mainstream media’s frequently superficial treatment of Hispanic-relevant issues is due partly to its general market focus, and partly to an under-formed understanding of these issues, the Hispanic media’s shortcomings are due largely to a lack of resources, particularly among local newspapers and independently owned Web sites, says Dr. Subervi: “One fantastic site that was undermined by a lack of funding is CandidatoUSA. They had highly-detailed and insightful coverage of the campaigns, but simply ran out of money. It would have taken about $50,000 to sustain the site’s rigorous coverage on through November, but they just couldn’t do it.” As a result, he says, the site has been forced to drastically pare-down its coverage.
Strained budgets among smaller Hispanic papers have also resulted in partisan “propaganda” being published under the guise of objective reporting, says Dr. Subervi. “It’s called ‘Planting News.’ I’ve seen instances of the same RNC-authored opinion column—verbatim—running in different Hispanic newspapers under different bylines.” Subervi notes that for a paper with limited editorial and economic resources, a ready-to-print political piece that is offered free-of-charge can be a tempting proposition.
Despite the overall lack of in-depth Hispanic political coverage presently available, Dr. Subervi notes that the media landscape is changing for the better, albeit slowly. He cites Impremedia’s political coverage as being among the best available. “La Opinion, in particular, has done a great job. At one point they had as many as six journalists traveling with the campaigns and reporting on them, which is really unprecedented in the history of Hispanic political reporting.” In the digital arena, Subervi cites votolatino.org as a good resource for Hispanic political coverage.
Speaking to which mediums are the most effective platforms through which to reach U.S. Hispanics, Dr. Subervi says, “Television remains the most influential medium for conveying Hispanic political coverage, because it is the most accessible medium to many people. After all, not every town has a Hispanic newspaper.”
While the mainstream news media is often accused of having a “liberal bias” (though no one would levy that criticism against the decidedly “mainstream” Fox News), Subervi says that there is no such perception in Hispanic media. “It’s very hard to generalize about widespread bias in Hispanic media, because it varies by market. Miami’s Diario Las Americas, for example, is a conservative bastion, and not surprisingly given the largely conservative Cuban-American audience that it caters to. By contrast, Los Angeles’ La Opinion and New York’s Diario La Prensa are viewed as more sympathetic to Democratic values,” which very much reflects the political temperature of those markets, says Dr. Subervi.
By: Portada-online.com
June 14, 2008
The Role of Mainstream/Hispanic Media in the Latino Vote
June 11, 2008
Spanish-language media key to victory with Latinos
While the dust was still settling last week in the Democratic presidential race between Barack Obama and Hillary Rodham Clinton, presumptive Republican nominee John McCain was kicking up his general election advertising war — on Spanish-language radio.
Smart move.
Obama, the Democratic survivor, is still figuring out how to win over the huge Hispanic voting bloc that strongly favored Clinton in the primaries. But McCain already has begun his Hispanic media campaign — in Spanish and English — in the hopes of copying the successes that President Bush had with those voters.
Republican candidates spent more advertising dollars to woo Hispanic voters in recent presidential elections, and Bush won two terms in the White House with 40 percent of the Latino vote.
But with the Democratic Party finally realizing it cannot take Hispanics for granted, the McCain campaign is bracing for the toughest competition ever for Latino support.
After introducing its first Spanish television ad in April and then going back onto Spanish radio in New Mexico and Nevada last week, the McCain campaign has produced 10 other ads targeting Hispanics that will roll out when the time is right.
“We know that what’s going to be different is that we have a smarter opponent than ever before,” said Lionel Sosa, McCain’s top Hispanic media strategist, who has worked with Bush and other Republicans for decades. Obama’s campaign will be “bigger, stronger, smarter than ever before,” Sosa predicted.
There is another striking difference in this year’s Latino campaign.
In the 2000 and 2004 presidential contests, Bush was comfortable enough with Spanish to regularly use it in his campaigns against former Vice President Al Gore and Massachusetts Sen. John F. Kerry, who did not speak the language. This year the situation is reversed, as Obama recently proved when he spoke directly into the television camera in a Spanish-language ad that aired during the Puerto Rico primary.
Obama’s Spanish ads are “quite good,” and Obama “apparently has learned Spanish well enough to do his own commercials,” Sosa said. “But it’s not who knows the language best. It’s who knows Latinos best, and there’s no doubt that McCain knows Latinos best.”
The candidates’ messages are more important than the language in which they are delivered. Still, the changing demographics of the U.S. Latino population have complicated how the candidates communicate with Hispanic communities.
In previous years, English-dominant second- and third-generation Latinos were the likely voters. Now, almost half of Hispanic voters are foreign-born. NDN, a progressive Democratic group, estimates that about eight out of 10 Hispanics speak Spanish at home.
There are other signs of the growing Hispanic market. There are now 872 Spanish-language radio stations in the U.S., up from 587 in 2000, according to Arbitron, which tracks radio listeners.
Arbitron also noted that the “key growing and emerging” Hispanic markets — in addition to those that are already well-established — are outside the Miami area and in South Carolina, Tennessee, Georgia, Indiana and Nevada.
Hispanics could determine the outcome of the McCain/Obama contest in New Mexico, Colorado, Nevada and Florida, states that Bush won by less than 5 percent of the vote in 2004.
English and Spanish radio is considered the best media source for Hispanics, but Spanish-language television news also is a powerful presence in the lives of Latinos.
The local television newscasts of the top-rated Univision Spanish-language network lead in 16 markets, including Las Vegas, Miami and Albuquerque, N.M., according to an NDN study.
“We are going to see the most money spent on Spanish-language media than we have ever seen before,” said Simon Rosenberg, president of NDN. READ MORE
By: GEBE MARTINEZ - Politico.com